Least Flycatcher (Empidonax minimus) (1)
- Reported Nov 14, 2026 08:06 by Forrest Wickman
- Prospect Park, Kings, New York
- Map: http://maps.google.com/?ie=UTF8&t=p&z=13&q=40.6602841,-73.9689534&ll=40.6602841,-73.9689534
- Checklist: https://ebird.org/checklist/S410596684
- Media: 1 Video, 10 Photos
- Comments: "Flagged as rare: very late. A real rollercoaster for many of us today, and seemingly a lesson in how, with Empidonax flycatchers, it’s best to trust your ears (and audio) over your eyes (or photos). I first detected this bird by its “wit” calls, which is why I didn’t immediately leap to it being a vagrant, despite the very late (though I think not unprecedented) date: It certainly sounded to me like a Least Flycatcher, and I didn’t see any problem with how it looked. (I admittedly don’t have much confidence with identifying these birds by primary projection, which was the main point in favor of Hammond’s, but it also seems like that’s something to be done with caution.) After I circulated photos and solicited more opinions, it began to be identified as a probable Hammond’s, which the bird did in some ways resemble, and I was encouraged to send out word, so I did, bringing in dozens of birders. (An issue during this period was that I couldn’t get my audio out of Merlin to share, because my Merlin keeps freezing. I’m all ears on how to fix that.) Then, after more audio (courtesy of Josh M—thanks to him for recording and to Eleanor R for refinding), and many more photos, and a bit of a reality check from Jay McGowan, the consensus began to shift back toward Least, which still seems to me like a fine ID for this bird. Whew! Still a cool record, if not quite the vagrant many of us were hoping for today."
- Reported Nov 14, 2026 08:06 by Forrest Wickman
- Prospect Park, Kings, New York
- Map: http://maps.google.com/?ie=UTF8&t=p&z=13&q=40.6602841,-73.9689534&ll=40.6602841,-73.9689534
- Checklist: https://ebird.org/checklist/S410596684
- Media: 1 Video, 10 Photos
- Comments: "Flagged as rare: very late. A real rollercoaster for many of us today, and seemingly a lesson in how, with Empidonax flycatchers, it’s best to trust your ears (and audio) over your eyes (or photos). I first detected this bird by its “wit” calls, which is why I didn’t immediately leap to it being a vagrant, despite the very late (though I think not unprecedented) date: It certainly sounded to me like a Least Flycatcher, and I didn’t see any problem with how it looked. (I admittedly don’t have much confidence with identifying these birds by primary projection, which was the main point in favor of Hammond’s, but it also seems like that’s something to be done with caution.) After I circulated photos and solicited more opinions, it began to be identified as a probable Hammond’s, which the bird did in some ways resemble, and I was encouraged to send out word, so I did, bringing in dozens of birders. (An issue during this period was that I couldn’t get my audio out of Merlin to share, because my Merlin keeps freezing. I’m all ears on how to fix that.) Then, after more audio (courtesy of Josh M—thanks to him for recording and to Eleanor R for refinding), and many more photos, and a bit of a reality check from Jay McGowan, the consensus began to shift back toward Least, which still seems to me like a fine ID for this bird. Whew! Still a cool record, if not quite the vagrant many of us were hoping for today."
"Learn from yesterday. Live for today. Look to tomorrow. Rest this afternoon."
Snoopy, "Peanuts"